The Russian Meeting Place: A place to meet people and talk about all things Russian...

International Discussions about Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, Travel, Music, Russian News, Ukrainian culture, Belarusian Dating, Moscow, Saint Petersburg, Kiev and other intelligent topics about life in the former Soviet Union.

     


                                

              

Pages: 1

are REALLY there all these success stories agencies tell us?

(Click here to view the original thread with full colors/images)


Posted by: ham

Quote:
Just like the Ukrainian girl that was murdered here (in Los Angeles) by her boyfriend.

Was her husband suprised to learn about her secret life - a NEW Mercedes, a boyfriend and the house she was buying with this boyfriend.

She was 21 and he was in his mid to late 50's




this validates another point of mine:
are really there all those success stories agencies etc tell us about?!


besides glamorous cases of hollywood styled divorces & murder, we must understand these old(er) men, who later fall victims of infidelity & a trip to the cleaners, were -at some point- part of those overwhelming, countless success stories as agencies & parties with vested interests to do so would let believe.

Elsewhere i posted sources claiming the number of FSU-MOBs is ridiculous.

Interesting enough, even people from the above site, who otherwise show an analytical mind about the men/women struggle, in the end feed the public a bunch of outdated & overboard lies.

Now, let's concede for the sake of the argument that a bunch of such "success stories" exist.
In fact i'm not questioning there may be a few hundreds of happy, lasting MOB marriages...but numbers don't add up with what you read over the net.

1. Joe Bob is a novice. We all thought FSUWs might be the best thing since sliced bread, at one time or another. Well said, however, FSUWs are women from a different country, not a different planet . That says all. Besides, divorce % in the FSU are the same or worse than in the west...that should tell you something, unless you believe the urban legend Russian men are all jobless, violent drunkards.

2. Joe Bob is freshly married or filed application, but every "new" thing seems to work well. I can count on my fingers men claiming to have been successfully married for 5, 10+ years. Oftentimes a few men are recorded as "success stories" (especially by agencies ), then nobody knows what happens later down the road. I just read a couple news items about a) a man whose brokered model FSU wife was murdered by her lover (!!) and b) divorces. Of course these late "insuccess stories" are very rarely brought in the picture or oh well, the man was the usual pig, fat, old, abuse-prone cheap loser for only losers seek MOBs. Read a few MOB forums and you'll realize most FSUWs in the WWW/LD/MOB arena have a very poor opinion of men going that way. Yes, that includes YOU & ME & that's no use claiming we have lines of models ready for a date & we're the hit at the bar/pub scene...well, at least i'm not, otherwise i wouldn't be here, right?

Quote:
As far as Stats. 30-48 percent start the k-1 process after meeting a lady at the parties that come though with a tour group. 50-60 percent start the k-1 process that is in the city with the agency. The main reason for a difference is the men who are part of the agency are visiting Kherson for a longer duration then you find with a tour group. About 50-60 percent will end up getting married in the long run.
typical agency claim=false

Quote:
Kyle Steckel (from EC) probably thinks I am engaged to some gal from Sochi that I never saw again after I left at the end of the tour. I stayed in touch with 4 guys on one tour. All 4 thought they had met someone at the close of the tour and were talking about the ins and outs of K-1's. Not one is still involved with that person that they met. I thought my one buddy from Atlanta was going to be our one success story but when I talked to him he had broken it off with his gal, (or the other way around).


this another opinion from someone likely to have been counted as a success story a dozen times...who never happened to be one.

When polled by INS, junk dating farms boasted they had arranged countless marriages (more FSUWS than INS had ever known about ) but alas...they were unable to provide information up to date...you know...relocation, name/address change...reasonable, isn't it?

Numbers claimed by agencies are skewed, fantasy unsubstantiated numbers.
That said, nobody ever bothers following what happens 3,5,10 years down a success story's road unless -again- we read about it because of murder or other hollywood sensational stuff.

Often people rebut happy people have no reason to come in the open to vent...because they're busy being a success story.
Well, i didn't see those people you read about in the news coming in the open to vent, either...and they're a blatant insuccess.

As well, over the years a few non whites ( asians, africans etc ) have made a point to announce how easy & feasible for them was getting a piece of white a$$ in the FSU.
Some of their "success letters" still appear on the web.
Too bad you meet them later on bitter & disgruntled after disappointing experiences or a trip to the cleaners.
Yet they still are counted as success stories elsewhere.

Others challenge the credibility of this assumption & explain a fact away with the "loser theory" claiming the single man involved was a loser, an abuse-prone social misfit & other popcorn psychology categories.

i say: buyer beware



Posted by: ira156

Quote:
Originally Posted by ham
this validates another point of mine:
are really there all those success stories agencies etc tell us about?!


besides glamorous cases of hollywood styled divorces & murder, we must understand these old(er) men, who later fall victims of infidelity & a trip to the cleaners, were -at some point- part of those overwhelming, countless success stories as agencies & parties with vested interests to do so would let believe.

Elsewhere i posted sources claiming the number of FSU-MOBs is ridiculous.

Interesting enough, even people from the above site, who otherwise show an analytical mind about the men/women struggle, in the end feed the public a bunch of outdated & overboard lies.

Now, let's concede for the sake of the argument that a bunch of such "success stories" exist.
In fact i'm not questioning there may be a few hundreds of happy, lasting MOB marriages...but numbers don't add up with what you read over the net.

1. Joe Bob is a novice. We all thought FSUWs might be the best thing since sliced bread, at one time or another. Well said, however, FSUWs are women from a different country, not a different planet . That says all. Besides, divorce % in the FSU are the same or worse than in the west...that should tell you something, unless you believe the urban legend Russian men are all jobless, violent drunkards.

2. Joe Bob is freshly married or filed application, but every "new" thing seems to work well. I can count on my fingers men claiming to have been successfully married for 5, 10+ years. Oftentimes a few men are recorded as "success stories" (especially by agencies ), then nobody knows what happens later down the road. I just read a couple news items about a) a man whose brokered model FSU wife was murdered by her lover (!!) and b) divorces. Of course these late "insuccess stories" are very rarely brought in the picture or oh well, the man was the usual pig, fat, old, abuse-prone cheap loser for only losers seek MOBs. Read a few MOB forums and you'll realize most FSUWs in the WWW/LD/MOB arena have a very poor opinion of men going that way. Yes, that includes YOU & ME & that's no use claiming we have lines of models ready for a date & we're the hit at the bar/pub scene...well, at least i'm not, otherwise i wouldn't be here, right?

typical agency claim=false



this another opinion from someone likely to have been counted as a success story a dozen times...who never happened to be one.

When polled by INS, junk dating farms boasted they had arranged countless marriages (more FSUWS than INS had ever known about ) but alas...they were unable to provide information up to date...you know...relocation, name/address change...reasonable, isn't it?

Numbers claimed by agencies are skewed, fantasy unsubstantiated numbers.
That said, nobody ever bothers following what happens 3,5,10 years down a success story's road unless -again- we read about it because of murder or other hollywood sensational stuff.

Often people rebut happy people have no reason to come in the open to vent...because they're busy being a success story.
Well, i didn't see those people you read about in the news coming in the open to vent, either...and they're a blatant insuccess.

As well, over the years a few non whites ( asians, africans etc ) have made a point to announce how easy & feasible for them was getting a piece of white a$$ in the FSU.
Some of their "success letters" still appear on the web.
Too bad you meet them later on bitter & disgruntled after disappointing experiences or a trip to the cleaners.
Yet they still are counted as success stories elsewhere.

Others challenge the credibility of this assumption & explain a fact away with the "loser theory" claiming the single man involved was a loser, an abuse-prone social misfit & other popcorn psychology categories.

i say: buyer beware



Hey Ham. Great to see you back spreading words of incaluable wisdom. I have just 2 questions for you.

1) do you know ANYONE thats happy?????

2) Can you please give me YOUR formula that has made you such a happy and positive person????



Posted by: bobjf

Quote:
Originally Posted by ira156
Hey Ham. Great to see you back spreading words of incaluable wisdom. I have just 2 questions for you.

1) do you know ANYONE thats happy?????

2) Can you please give me YOUR formula that has made you such a happy and positive person????



ahh 1 of RMP'S unsolved mysteries



Posted by: ira156

Quote:
Originally Posted by bobjf
ahh 1 of RMP'S unsolved mysteries

Hey Bob its one that has me baffled.....i guess we'll have to wait till your on deaths door for you to post that you and Nat are Happy????



Posted by: bobjf

Quote:
Originally Posted by ira156
Hey Bob its one that has me baffled.....i guess we'll have to wait till your on deaths door for you to post that you and Nat are Happy????


yep guess your right ian,some people just won't beleive its possable & i scarsely beleive that i'm alone.

ham freak us out & post something happy,positive



Posted by: ham

Quote:
Hey Ham. Great to see you back spreading words of incaluable wisdom. I have just 2 questions for you.


i could play the self-important "success", dilate upon "how we here... " and whatever, but i still have common sense. You have fun.
Nothing new under the sun, as someone honestly wrote:
Quote:
You must understand, just a month ago, I was reading all of the posts about guys who got burned and how there were very few success stories. I always would feel happy and joyful saying to myself "HEY, I'M A SUCCESS STORY; I'VE GOT A RUSSIAN LADY WHO LOVES ME AND WILL BE WITH ME FOREVER !" That was until I found out that she was screwing her boyfriend two or three times per week, discribing to him how much of a FOOL that I was for believing her made up lies and false truths. She was litterally LAUGHING at how stupid I was for believing her at what she was telling me. I recorded her conversations on digital voice recorders (3 of them) spread around the apartment when I was at work.


You focus on me, instead, and how much better you feel online drawing comparisons with me, or what you think i am...

Quote:
Can you please give me YOUR formula that has made you such a happy and positive person????


ah...it's a twist of "it's the other guy who's the real looser"...you crack me up.

Quote:
ham freak us out & post something happy,positive


No scammer will have a cent from me.

http://russianmeetingplace.com/foru...ead.php?t=14810

I see no knight in shining armor commented on the above.
it's not made up...you got names from a press article.
Perhaps they think "it's the other guy who's a loser", "signs were all over to see" and the like, much like they are telling anyone who reports being scammed or whose relationship went south.
When push will come to shove, and i wish you it never will, we will see how much of a real tough boy you are.
In the meantime, i suspend my belief and remain skeptical.



Posted by: bobjf

Quote:
Originally Posted by ham
i could play the self-important "success", dilate upon "how we here... " and whatever, but i still have common sense. You have fun.
Nothing new under the sun, as someone honestly wrote:


You focus on me, instead, and how much better you feel online drawing comparisons with me, or what you think i am...



ah...it's a twist of "it's the other guy who's the real looser"...you crack me up.



No scammer will have a cent from me.

http://russianmeetingplace.com/foru...ead.php?t=14810

I see no knight in shining armor commented on the above.
it's not made up...you got names from a press article.
Perhaps they think "it's the other guy who's a loser", "signs were all over to see" and the like, much like they are telling anyone who reports being scammed or whose relationship went south.
When push will come to shove, and i wish you it never will, we will see how much of a real tough boy you are.
In the meantime, i suspend my belief and remain skeptical.



ohh dear i knew it was to much to ask.
life is an adventure mate,if you never never try you'll never never know, go on smile & have a great day
cheers



Posted by: ham

As the forum rules suggest, people should discuss a topic, not a person.
But since ( i guess...) the topic cannot be disproved, then some people prefer to discuss ME, instead.
I may be a 78yo white farmer, or a 15yo pakistani kid; a millionaire or a beggar; a triple Ph.D in astrophysics or a middle school dropout...none of which will affect the truth in the topic, or one's chances at it.
Awareness is extremely positive, so that fewer&fewer men fall victims of scams or of their own delusions/fantasy.



Many agencies rose, shone & disappeared; huge profits were/are made...alright. But nobody will be there when people hit the ground, and nobody will feel sorry.



Posted by: joelunchbox

The crux of this thread is "Have mariages to FSU ladies been quantified?"
When you read something, is it true? is it sensationalized? Do normal/happy marriages make it to the papers? Waht ages and age differences are we looking at?
Wouldn't you think that someone somewhere would be keeping track of this?
I htink the govt is beginning to, due to the additional blocks on the 129. The govt is worried that physically abusive people are looking for spouses overseas.



Posted by: ham

Quote:
Wouldn't you think that someone somewhere would be keeping track of this?


INS studies i read ( and posted links to elsewhere ) claimed MOB marriages stand no better chance than domestic ones. It makes sense considering raw divorce rate ( i examined them as well elsewhere ) from census sites, which can be roughly compared.
The same INS studies claimed abuse in MOB marriages was either 1% or non detectable.
But studies might be manipulated as political opportunity dictates.
As well, there are few undocumented, uncredited studies around, some which expose failure rates upto 80%, others that claim the opposite.



Posted by: stevo

Quote:
Originally Posted by joelunchbox
The govt is worried that physically abusive people are looking for spouses overseas.

I think that's a convenient cover story for wanting to make it difficult for people to look for spouses overseas.



Posted by: joelunchbox

Wouldn't it be nice if they tracked data more distinctly? ages of couples, how many prior marriages, etc? instead of just dumping us into one bucket?

and the political angle is not lost on me... I think that the additonal lines on the form are just CYA for the agencies...



Posted by: scotch

I don't think anyone is denying that foreign relationships are any easier than local ones, in fact they are probably fraught with more hurdles because of language and employment difficulties .. and the tendency (from what I see) of guys rushing headlong into a marriage with the first girl who pays them any attention.

But from what I gather from hanging out here for a while is that most guys have been burnt before, usually several times over by local women. They have become angry and pessimistic and are desperately seeking someone to prove to them that not all women are whining, grumpy, superficial scumbags.

Unfortunately all FSU women can write whatever they want in their profiles to cater to these needs of Western men, and likewise, agency websites (who want to stay in business) will offer a solution to these needs, regardless of whether the product matches their claims.

Ham plays the devil's advocate, but I think it is necessary in order to have balance in these matters (since the reality is that some FSU women and agencies do scam) .. those of us who have found our love can't comment because we have no idea what it's like to be truly scammed.

So whatever the agencies say, whatever the profiles say .. don't enter into communication with any stereotypes about russian women because every woman is an individual that will be different to the next. Sure they might all wear slippers in the house and love beetroot, but every one of them has a unique personality that can't be isolated or generalised.

Talk to girls from an aussie dating site (eg. http://www.rsvp.com.au/) and a REAL Russian dating site (http://love.mail.ru/) and there is hardly any difference between them (except russian girls are less *****y )

scotch.



Posted by: joelunchbox

I think it is important to digest everything you read/see and then use your head and think about your particular situation.
for example: My visit to tashkent. on the fifth day or so, she asked me if I could buy her a cell phone. For an instant bells and whistles went off. Then I thought that she hadn't asked for anything before then and the way she asked was very ....not pushy. and she was going to buy the minutes for it. I wish I had known earlier about her cell phone desire so maybe I could have bought one here and saved some money (hers was $50 and I don't know if that is/was a good/bad deal). But, she may have been worried that if she asked earlier I would see her as a scammer... $50 to me is a bit of money but I am fairly certain that to her it is a LOT of money. Anyway, I bought the phone, and it appears to be making her fairly happy-able to call her mother (fairly old) and her daughter while she is at work.
I don't think it is fair to say that every time something happens it always means something. it could mean a lot of things, yes?
But, it is good to see the things that could mean trouble and that helps us be aware of our situation.



Russian America Top. Рейтинг ресурсов Русской Америки. Рейтинг@Mail.ru Russian Network USA



Russian Meeting Place Copyright ©2000 - 2008, www.russianmeetingplace.com and Khahsyar and Lena.